AgentOps 3.0 Council Verdict Example

HISTORICAL SAMPLE: This 3.0 example includes retired AO/BR surfaces and illustrative verdicts. It is not a current execution recipe. Use native BD and the current evidence contracts for live work.

This is public sample output for the 3.0 explainer kit. It is an example artifact shape, not PMF evidence or a claim that a live mixed council completed.

Run Metadata

Field	Value
Packet	.agents/packets/agentops-3-launch.md
Briefing	.agents/rpi/briefing-current.md
Decision	Should the 3.0 launch demo lead with council-first engineering judgment?
Mode	Mixed Claude/Codex when available; /council --quick fallback allowed for local proof
Artifact	.agents/council/<run-id>/verdict.md

Consolidated Verdict

Status: WARN

Lead with the council-first engineering judgment demo. Keep the out-of-session NTM + Agent Mail substrate and software-factory automation as the second-stage lane after the viewer has seen one visible domain/practice packet and one verdict artifact.

The launch copy should be updated before publication to avoid unsupported productivity, PMF, or autonomous-factory claims.

Judge Notes

Judge	Assessment
Claude product judge	PASS: council-first is the clearest first value because the user sees taste, judgment, and shared context immediately.
Claude engineering-practice judge	PASS: the domain/practice packet encodes DDD/TDD/BDD/review/release discipline before implementation begins.
Codex implementation judge	PASS: existing ao quick-start, ao context assemble, /council, br, and .agents/ surfaces can support the path.
Codex release-risk judge	WARN: public copy must avoid PMF and speed claims until exported evidence exists.

Evidence Used

• PRODUCT.md
• GOALS.md
• docs/examples/agentops-3-domain-practice-packet.md
• docs/first-value-path.md
• docs/activation-profiles.md
• soc-m6v5.9.7

Required Follow-Up

1. Point README and launch content at the first-value path.
2. Show .agents/council/<run-id>/verdict.md before any out-of-session substrate automation.
3. Use BEADS_DIR="$(ao beads dir)" br create ... --body "From .agents/council/<run-id>/verdict.md" for tracked follow-up work.
4. Keep ao activate product-council deferred until repeated PMF runs prove the profile is stable.

Claim Posture

Allowed public language:

• "engineering operating system for agent teams"
• "disciplined engineering layer for agentic software development"
• "from agent opinions to engineering verdicts"
• "bring your agent, bring your harness"

Blocked until exported evidence exists:

• PMF claims.
• Specific productivity or speedup numbers.
• Fully autonomous factory as the first-value promise.
• Regulated or certified-operation claims.